Description
Need a Thanksgiving writing activity that keeps students engaged while giving them meaningful practice with opinion writing? This Pie Opinion Writing Project guides students through the writing process, from brainstorming to publishing, and ends with a festive pie craft you can display in your classroom or hallway!
Students answer one delicious question: What’s the best pie flavor? Then they support their opinion with reasons, organize their ideas, edit their work, and publish their final writing.
With five days of lesson plans, two leveled rough draft options, and printable pie templates, you’ll have a clear plan for bringing seasonal fun into your writing block.
WHAT’S INCLUDED?
• Five days of teacher lesson plans with modeling suggestions, discussion prompts, and directions for guiding students through each stage
• Brainstorming page for choosing a pie flavor and generating supporting reasons
• Two leveled rough draft options so you can adjust the amount of support students receive
• Sentence starters and conclusion starters to help students introduce and restate their opinions
• Student editing checklist to guide students as they review their writing
• Two final draft pages that connect to create the writing portion of the finished craft
• Two pie template styles, including a lattice pie and an open filling pie
• Color and black-and-white pie options so students can color their own or use the provided color versions
• Step-by-step assembly directions for turning students’ writing into a finished pie display
PRACTICE REAL WRITING SKILLS
The finished craft gives students a fun reason to publish their work, while the lessons keep the focus on developing their writing.
Students practice:
• Stating a clear opinion
• Brainstorming reasons that support their opinion
• Choosing three reasons to include in their writing
• Expanding reasons with more detail
• Using transition words to organize ideas
• Writing a conclusion that restates their opinion
• Reading their writing aloud to check for mistakes
• Checking capitalization, punctuation, and possible spelling errors
• Copying revised writing into a neat final draft
TWO ROUGH DRAFT OPTIONS FOR DIFFERENT LEVELS OF SUPPORT
Have students who need help getting started and others who are ready for more independence? Choose the draft format that fits their needs.
More scaffolding: Includes the transition words “First,” “Second,” and “Lastly,” with two writing lines for each section.
Less scaffolding: Leaves transition words for students to supply and provides three writing lines per section for more detailed responses.
Both versions include sentence starters, conclusion starters, and an editing checklist. Students can work toward the same finished project with different amounts of support along the way.
A CLEAR PLAN FOR YOUR WRITING BLOCK
Day 1: Mentor Text and Brainstorming
Introduce the project with a suggested pie-themed read-aloud, discuss favorite flavors, and model brainstorming reasons. Students choose their own pie flavor and generate ideas.
Day 2: Model the Writing
Work together to write a class example. Model how to state an opinion, choose supporting reasons, add detail, and write a conclusion.
Day 3: Write the Rough Draft
Guide students as they turn their brainstorming into an organized opinion piece using the appropriate draft option.
Day 4: Edit and Publish
Model the editing process, have students review their work, and begin copying their revised writing onto the final draft pages.
Day 5: Assemble and Display
Students finish their writing, color their pie pieces if needed, and assemble their projects. Display the finished pies for a Thanksgiving writing celebration!
A SIMPLE CRAFT WITH A PURPOSE
The pie templates attach above and below the final writing pages, creating a long pie-shaped writing display. Students can personalize the black-and-white templates to match their chosen flavor, from cherry or pumpkin to chocolate cream or their own favorite.
You’ll have a festive display that showcases students’ ideas and the work they put into the writing process.
PERFECT FOR:
• Thanksgiving writing lessons
• November opinion writing practice
• A guided writing project across one school week
• Whole-class writing instruction and modeling
• A seasonal classroom bulletin board
• A hallway display before Thanksgiving break
WHAT WILL YOU NEED?
Print the student pages and your preferred pie templates. Students will need pencils, scissors, and glue, plus crayons or colored pencils if you choose the black-and-white pie option.
The teacher guide suggests Peyton Picks the Perfect Pie by Jack Bishop or I Know an Old Lady Who Swallowed a Pie by Alison Jackson for the introductory read-aloud. Mentor texts are not included.
Give your students a Thanksgiving project they’ll be excited to write! Add this Pie Opinion Writing Project to your November plans and guide them from their first ideas to a finished piece they’re proud to display.
